Data Licensing News
Who is buying AI training data, what they pay, and what the courts just did.Subscribe on Substack
PayoutsPolicy

Scale AI's proposed $12.5 million California wage settlement names Outlier; Mercor faces a misclassification suit in Texas

The McKinney settlement administrator had not posted a final approval when we checked on Nov. 17. In White v. Mercor, an amended motion to compel arbitration is pending.

Scale AI, Smart Ecosystem, HireArt, and several individual defendants will pay $12,500,000 as the gross settlement amount in McKinney, et al. v. Scale AI, Inc., et al., San Francisco Superior Court Case No. CGC-24-620481, under a proposed settlement described in the court-approved class notice. The court granted preliminary approval and set a final approval hearing for October 30, 2026, at 9:00 a.m.

When we opened the administrator's settlement website on Nov. 17, 2026, it still said "The Court has not yet decided whether to grant final approval." We have not seen a final approval order, so we describe the settlement as proposed.

The settlement class covers people who, from December 10, 2020 through February 28, 2026, worked as Contributors while living in California. Per the notice, that includes people with a California address on an account on the defendants' platforms, "including Outlier or Remotasks," and Contributors include people classified as independent contractors in roles such as generative AI annotators, prompt engineers, and subject matter experts.

The $12.5 million is not what workers receive. The notice says it also covers up to $4,166,666.67 in attorneys' fees, up to $100,000 in litigation expenses, service payments of up to $15,000 to each named plaintiff, up to $100,000 for administration, and a $500,000 PAGA payment. Defendants "strongly deny violating any laws" and maintain that Contributors are independent contractors, and the notice says settling is not an admission.

In Texas, Heidi L. White's putative class action against Mercor.io Corporation, No. 6:26-cv-00201-H in the Northern District of Texas, San Angelo Division, alleges that Mercor misclassified the experts it supplies to train AI models as independent contractors and reported their pay on Forms 1099-NEC instead of W-2s, according to the first amended complaint, Dkt. 16, filed June 25, 2026. Its claims include a subclass under 26 U.S.C. section 7434 over those forms. These are allegations, not findings.

On Nov. 12, 2026, Judge James Wesley Hendrix denied as moot Mercor's original motion to compel arbitration, strike the class allegations, and stay or dismiss the case. Mercor's amended version of that motion, Dkt. 19, remains pending, along with the plaintiff's motion for limited discovery, Dkt. 22, according to the docket on PACER Monitor.

Why it matters: the people who write and grade AI training data are mostly paid as contractors, and that model is now being tested in court. A proposed settlement is not a ruling that anyone was misclassified.

Sources

  1. Court-approved class notice, McKinney v. Scale AI, CGC-24-620481
  2. McKinney v. Scale AI settlement website (Simpluris), opened Nov. 17, 2026
  3. White v. Mercor.io Corp., first amended complaint, Dkt. 16 (CourtListener RECAP)
  4. White v. Mercor.io Corp. docket (PACER Monitor)

Spotted an error? See our corrections policy.

Related